The Malaysian Automotive Association (MAA) has called on the government to defer the mandatory implementation of emergency call devices until the industry is ready. The plan has proposed the devices to be implemented on all newly-registered vehicle starting from 2019.
Details of the proposed emergency call equipment are scarce, except that it is to come from one as-yet unnamed Malaysian supplier, an arrangement MAA president Datuk Aishah Ahmad has called ‘ridiculous’ because of possible major complications should there be any issues arising from that single supplier.
This is due to anticipated increases in eventual car prices if the e-call devices are implemented, as well as a lack of confirmed regulations and device specifications for the e-call device, she added.
The installation of the e-call devices into new motor vehicles can be very costly, said the MAA. This is due to the increase in excise duty, import tax and GST which will in turn increase the overall cost and subsequently the on-the-road price of a vehicle if the device is considered part of a vehicle, the association said.
It added that such a move would defeat efforts towards reducing car prices gradually in Malaysia, which was promised by the ruling government during the 13th General Election. The proposed January 2019 implementation also allows for too little lead time for the industry to comply, and there are also concerns that the benefits of the system will only be tangible when the necessary infrastructure is in place.
A comprehensive and holistic study is required to justify the mandatory implementation of the e-call service in Malaysia, MAA said in a statement. This study should include an analysis of road fatalities in Malaysia, and of any deficiencies in the notification of or response by emergency response teams, in order to support the proposal for the devices’ implementation.
To date, Russia is the only country known to have a similar setup in place – should this proposal receive the green light, Malaysia will be the second country globally to have emergency call devices installed in road-going vehicles.
The MAA also recommended that the e-call service and devices not be made mandatory for new vehicles in Malaysia.
Looking to sell your car? Sell it with Carro.
Omote
on 
john
on 
BABA
on 
Periasamy
on 
thepolygonal
on 
john
on 
GoodComplainBut
on 
Operation Manager
on 
DK
on 
tokmoh.
on 
Top
on 
Rashidi Arabia
on 
john
on 
Woot Woot
on 
Henry
on 
Boring Samy is kunta
on 
llm
on 
pondan
on 
WT Fuchhh
on 
Anonymous
on 
sempua
on 
remove the smart tag first
on 
McQueen
on 
Blood sucking idea
on 
Afeeq
on 
dingle
on 
Emilio Davila
on 
Ahmadjr
on 
abc
on 
Blue
on 
ali
on 
smart
on 
johnnas
on 
camtakpro
on 
amoi
on 
bankrupt
on 
arowana
on 
Bernard
on 
Mr. Octopus
on 
ae101
on 
Not Toyota Fan
on 
Nicholas
on 
komarad
on 
Diss-illusions
on 
Fancy
on 
AI-generated Summary ✨
Comments express skepticism and criticism toward the e-call device proposal, citing concerns about cost, cronyism, and implementation inefficiency. Many point out that Malaysia already faces issues with safety standards like airbags and VSC, which should be priorities before new systems. There’s suspicion that the project benefits a single supplier or crony, with some suggesting it’s unnecessary and expensive. Several comments reference existing features like BMW's connected drive or EU mandates, questioning why Malaysia lags. Others emphasize that basic safety upgrades and enforcement of vehicle safety features are more urgent than this e-call system. Overall, the sentiment is largely negative, highlighting concerns about government motives, affordability, and the effectiveness of the proposed system.