Verdict
The RM116,000 gap is hard to ignore: the smart #5 costs RM209,800, delivers 358 hp and 373 Nm, reaches 100 km/h in 6.5 seconds and brings a 100 kWh battery rated for 590 km. Its 400 kW DC charging, 630-litre boot and 2,900 mm wheelbase suit an EV-minded Malaysian family. The BMW X3 counters with all-wheel drive, an 8-speed automatic, a higher 215 km/h top speed and local CKD assembly, but its 188 hp mild-hybrid petrol drivetrain needs 8.5 seconds to 100 km/h. The X3 is the conventional choice; the smart gives substantially more hardware per ringgit.
The X3 30 xDrive M Sport (RM358,800) sits above every #5 variant here, so the verdict compares the closest-priced pairing — use the selectors above to match any two trims.
Pick the BMW X3 if all-wheel drive, a 215 km/h top speed and an 8-speed petrol mild-hybrid drivetrain matter more than EV range and upfront savings.
Pick the smart #5 if you want 590 km of electric range, 400 kW DC charging, faster acceleration and RM116,000 left in your pocket.
Key differences
- Price: BMW X3 RM325,800; smart #5 RM209,800.
- Power and torque: BMW X3 188 hp and 310 Nm; smart #5 358 hp and 373 Nm.
- 0-100 km/h: BMW X3 8.5 seconds; smart #5 6.5 seconds.
- Driveline: BMW X3 all-wheel drive; smart #5 rear-wheel drive.
- Cargo space: BMW X3 570 litres; smart #5 630 litres.
- Wheelbase: BMW X3 2,865 mm; smart #5 2,900 mm.
X3
- All-wheel drive
- 215 km/h top speed
- CKD Malaysian assembly
- RM116,000 more expensive
- Slower 8.5-second 0-100 km/h time
- 570-litre boot is 60 litres smaller
#5
- 358 hp electric motor and 6.5-second 0-100 km/h time
- 100 kWh battery with 590 km range
- 400 kW DC charging and 3.3 kW V2L
- Rear-wheel drive instead of all-wheel drive
- 200 km/h top speed is 15 km/h lower
- CBU import from China rather than Malaysian CKD assembly
What the X3 has over the #5
What the #5 has over the X3
Based on the published spec sheets of the selected variants — a blank field on one side can also mean unlisted data.
Boot space favours the #5: 630 litres against 570.
Representative body-type outlines, drawn to scale from each car's length and height.
| Price & overview | ||
|---|---|---|
| Price | RM325,800 | RM209,800✓ |
| Body type | SUV | SUV |
| Segment | Compact Executive | Compact Executive |
| Assembly | CKD | CBU |
| Ownership | ||
| Road tax / year | RM439✓ | RM455 |
| Monthly instalment (est.) | RM3,325/mo | RM2,140/mo✓ |
| Insurance / year (est.) | RM8,784 | RM5,703✓ |
| Fuel or electricity / year (est.) | — | RM1,506 |
| Energy cost / 100 km (est.) | — | RM7.53 |
| 5-year running costs (est.) | — | RM38,319 |
| Charging (estimated) | ||
| AC charge 0–100% (est.) | — | 4.5 hours |
| DC charge 10–80% (est.) | — | 20 min |
| Powertrain | ||
| Engine Tech | 16-valve DOHC direct injection with twin-scroll turbocharger, variable valve timing and mild hybrid assistance | 800V architecture |
| Capacity | 1,998 cc | — |
| Horsepower | 188 hp at 4,400 rpm | — |
| Torque | 310 Nm at 1,500 rpm | — |
| Cylinder Arrangement | Inline 4 | — |
| Fuel | Petrol Hybrid/REV | Electric |
| Number of Motors | — | 1 |
| Motor Horsepower | — | 358 hp |
| Motor Torque | — | 373 Nm |
| Battery Capacity | — | 100 kWh |
| EV Range | — | 590 km |
| Charging Rate (AC) | — | 22 kW |
| Charging Rate (DC) | — | 400 kW |
| V2L | — | 3.3 kW |
| Drivetrain | ||
| Transmission | Conventional Automatic | Single Ratio Automatic |
| Transmission Name | 8-speed Steptronic | — |
| Gears | 8 | — |
| Transmission Manufacturer | ZF | — |
| Driveline | All Wheel Drive | Rear Wheel Drive |
| Performance & Efficiency | ||
| 0-100 km/h | 8.5 seconds | 6.5 seconds✓ |
| Top Speed | 215 km/h✓ | 200 km/h |
| Dimensions | ||
| Length | 4,755 mm | 4,705 mm |
| Width | 1,920 mm | 1,920 mm |
| Height | 1,660 mm | 1,705 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2,865 mm | 2,900 mm |
| Weight | — | 2,260 kg |
| Doors | 5 | 5 |
| Seats | 5 | 5 |
| Boot Space | 570 litres | 630 litres✓ |
| Front Tyre | 245/50R19 | 255/45R20 |
| Rear Tyre | 245/50R19 | 255/45R20 |
| Spare Tyre | N/A, Tyre Repair Kit | — |
| Factory Tyres | Continental EcoContact 6 Q | Continental EcoContact 7 |
| Wiper Blade (Driver) | 24 inch | 24 inch |
| Wiper Blade (Passenger) | 19 inch | 20 inch |
| Chassis | ||
| Assembly | Malaysia (CKD) | China (CBU) |
| Front Suspension | MacPherson Strut | Double Wishbones |
| Rear Suspension | Multi-link | Multi-link |
| Front Wheels | 19" Y-spoke M Alloys | 20" Alloys |
| Rear Wheels | 19" Y-spoke M Alloys | 20" Alloys |
| Steering | Rack & Pinion (Electric Power Steering) | Rack and Pinion (Electric Power Steering) |
| Safety | ||
| Airbags | 6 (Driver and Front Passenger, Front Side, Curtain Airbags) | 6 (Driver & Front Passenger, Side Airbags, Curtain Airbags) |
| ABS/EBD | ✓ | ✓ |
| Stability Control | ✓ | ✓ |
| Alarm | ✓ | ✓ |
| Immobilizer | ✓ | ✓ |
| Airbag Disable Function | ✓ | ✓ |
| Child Safety Lock | Manual for Rear Doors | Electronic for Rear Doors |
| Seat Belts | 5 Three-point | 5 Three-point |
| Blind Spot Info System | ✓ | ✓ |
| ISOFIX | Available for 2 Outer Rear Seats | Available On Front Passenger Seat, Rear Outer Seats |
| Autonomous Braking System | Yes | Yes, Front and Rear |
| Lane-keeping Assist | Steering Correction | Steering Correction |
| Collision Warning | ✓ | ✓ |
| Seatbelt Reminder | All Seats | All Seats |
| Lighting | ||
| Headlamps | LED Projector | LED Projectors with Auto High Beam & Auto Levelling |
| Taillamps | Full LED | Full LED |
| LED Daytime Running Lights | ✓ | ✓ |
| Rear Foglamps | ✓ | ✓ |
| Wing Mirror Turn Indicators | ✓ | ✓ |
| Cabin | ||
| Front Seats | Powered Front Seats | Driver and Passenger Powered Seats |
| Rear Seats | 40:20:40 Split-folding | 60:40 Split-fold with Sliding Adjustment |
| Front Air-con | Dual-zone Automatic Climate Control | Dual-zone Automatic Climate Control |
| Rear Air-con | Single-zone Automatic Climate Control | Rear AC Vents |
| Sunroof | — | Panoramic Glass Roof |
| Power Sockets | 1 Front, 1 Wireless Charger, 2 USB-C Front, 2 USB-C Rear | 1 Front, 2 Wireless Chargers, 2 USB-C Front, 2 USB-C Rear |
| Interior Lighting | Map Lights & Ambient Lighting | Map Lights & Ambient Lighting |
| Cup Holders | 2 Front, 2 Rear | 2 Front, 2 Rear |
| Sun Shade | — | Powered Sunroof Shade |
| Audio | 14.9" BMW Curved Display Live Cockpit Professional, 6 Speaker | 13" Twin AMOLED Touchscreens with Wireless Apple CarPlay & Android Auto, 20-speaker Sennheiser Sound System |
| Convenience | ||
| Power Windows | Four Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti-pinch | Four Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti Pinch |
| Engine Start | Keyless Push Button | Keyless (Depress Brake Pedal) |
| Locks | Keyless Operation | Keyless Operation |
| Auto Start/Stop | ✓ | — |
| Auto Headlamps | ✓ | ✓ |
| Auto Wipers | ✓ | ✓ |
| Cruise Control | Adaptive Cruise Control | Adaptive Cruise Control with Highway & Traffic Jam Assist |
| Paddle Shift | ✓ | — |
| Steering Audio Control | ✓ | ✓ |
| Steering Tilt | ✓ | ✓ |
| Steering Telescopic | ✓ | ✓ |
| Boot Operation | Powered Boot with Contactless Opening | Yes, Powered with Kick Sensor |
| Parking Sensor Front | 6 Sensors | 6 Sensors |
| Parking Sensor Rear | 6 Sensors | 6 Sensors |
| Reverse Camera | Yes, 360-degree View Monitor | Yes, With 360-degree Camera |
| Auto Parking | Yes | Yes |
| Folding Wing Mirrors | ✓ | ✓ |
| Bluetooth | ✓ | ✓ |
| Navigation | ✓ | ✓ |
| Head-up Display | ✓ | ✓ |
| Hill Start Assist | ✓ | ✓ |
| Instrument Cluster | Full LCD Monitor | Full LCD Monitor |
| Parking Brake | Electronic | Electronic |
| Warranty | ||
| Warranty Mileage Manufacturer | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Warranty Mileage Extended | Unlimited | — |
| Warranty Manufacturer | 2 years | 4 years✓ |
| Warranty Extended | 3 years | — |
| Warranty Notes | — | 8-year/200,000 km Battery Warranty & 8-year/150000 High Voltage Components Warranty |
Specs shown for the selected variant of each car. ✓ marks the better figure where lower/higher is objectively better. Road tax: West Malaysia, private registration. Running-cost estimates assume 20,000 km/year. Fuel at RM1.99/litre (RON95, subsidised). Electricity at RM0.44/kWh (TNB domestic, home charging); public DC charging costs around RM1.30/kWh. Charging times estimated from battery capacity and peak charging rates. Insurance: comprehensive motor tariff, no NCD. Instalment: 10% down, 2.5% flat rate, 9 years. Prices checked November 2026.
Used X3 & #5 for sale
Our reviews & guides
BMW X3
X3 vs #5 FAQ
Is the BMW X3 or smart #5 better?
The smart #5 is the stronger choice on price, performance, range, charging and boot space. Choose the BMW X3 specifically for all-wheel drive, Malaysian CKD assembly and its 215 km/h top speed.
What is the price difference?
The BMW X3 costs RM325,800 and the smart #5 costs RM209,800, so the BMW is RM116,000 more expensive.
Which one is faster and easier to charge?
The smart #5 is faster, reaching 100 km/h in 6.5 seconds versus 8.5 seconds for the X3. It also supports 22 kW AC and 400 kW DC charging; the petrol X3 does not require EV charging.
How long does charging take?
The #5's 100.0 kWh battery takes about 4.5 hours for a full AC charge, and an estimated 20 minutes from 10% to 80% on a DC fast charger at its 400 kW peak.
Which has the better warranty?
The #5 carries a 4-year manufacturer warranty against 2 years for the X3. #5: 8-year/200,000 km Battery Warranty & 8-year/150000 High Voltage Components Warranty.