Car Buyer's Guide

BMW X3 vs smart #5

BMW X3

BMW X3

smart #5

smart #5

Verdict

The RM116,000 gap is hard to ignore: the smart #5 costs RM209,800, delivers 358 hp and 373 Nm, reaches 100 km/h in 6.5 seconds and brings a 100 kWh battery rated for 590 km. Its 400 kW DC charging, 630-litre boot and 2,900 mm wheelbase suit an EV-minded Malaysian family. The BMW X3 counters with all-wheel drive, an 8-speed automatic, a higher 215 km/h top speed and local CKD assembly, but its 188 hp mild-hybrid petrol drivetrain needs 8.5 seconds to 100 km/h. The X3 is the conventional choice; the smart gives substantially more hardware per ringgit.

The X3 30 xDrive M Sport (RM358,800) sits above every #5 variant here, so the verdict compares the closest-priced pairing — use the selectors above to match any two trims.

X3

Pick the BMW X3 if all-wheel drive, a 215 km/h top speed and an 8-speed petrol mild-hybrid drivetrain matter more than EV range and upfront savings.

#5

Pick the smart #5 if you want 590 km of electric range, 400 kW DC charging, faster acceleration and RM116,000 left in your pocket.

Key differences

  • Price: BMW X3 RM325,800; smart #5 RM209,800.
  • Power and torque: BMW X3 188 hp and 310 Nm; smart #5 358 hp and 373 Nm.
  • 0-100 km/h: BMW X3 8.5 seconds; smart #5 6.5 seconds.
  • Driveline: BMW X3 all-wheel drive; smart #5 rear-wheel drive.
  • Cargo space: BMW X3 570 litres; smart #5 630 litres.
  • Wheelbase: BMW X3 2,865 mm; smart #5 2,900 mm.

X3

  • All-wheel drive
  • 215 km/h top speed
  • CKD Malaysian assembly
  • RM116,000 more expensive
  • Slower 8.5-second 0-100 km/h time
  • 570-litre boot is 60 litres smaller

#5

  • 358 hp electric motor and 6.5-second 0-100 km/h time
  • 100 kWh battery with 590 km range
  • 400 kW DC charging and 3.3 kW V2L
  • Rear-wheel drive instead of all-wheel drive
  • 200 km/h top speed is 15 km/h lower
  • CBU import from China rather than Malaysian CKD assembly

What the X3 has over the #5

Auto Start/StopPaddle Shift

What the #5 has over the X3

SunroofSun Shade

Based on the published spec sheets of the selected variants — a blank field on one side can also mean unlisted data.

Boot space favours the #5: 630 litres against 570.

X3 4,755 × 1,920 × 1,660 mm · wheelbase 2,865 mm#5 4,705 × 1,920 × 1,705 mm · wheelbase 2,900 mm
1,6604,755 mmWheelbase 2,865 mm1,7054,705 mmWheelbase 2,900 mm

Representative body-type outlines, drawn to scale from each car's length and height.

Price & overview
PriceRM325,800RM209,800✓
Body typeSUVSUV
SegmentCompact ExecutiveCompact Executive
AssemblyCKDCBU
Ownership
Road tax / yearRM439✓RM455
Monthly instalment (est.)RM3,325/moRM2,140/mo✓
Insurance / year (est.)RM8,784RM5,703✓
Fuel or electricity / year (est.)—RM1,506
Energy cost / 100 km (est.)—RM7.53
5-year running costs (est.)—RM38,319
Charging (estimated)
AC charge 0–100% (est.)—4.5 hours
DC charge 10–80% (est.)—20 min
Powertrain
Engine Tech16-valve DOHC direct injection with twin-scroll turbocharger, variable valve timing and mild hybrid assistance800V architecture
Capacity1,998 cc—
Horsepower188 hp at 4,400 rpm—
Torque310 Nm at 1,500 rpm—
Cylinder ArrangementInline 4—
FuelPetrol Hybrid/REVElectric
Number of Motors—1
Motor Horsepower—358 hp
Motor Torque—373 Nm
Battery Capacity—100 kWh
EV Range—590 km
Charging Rate (AC)—22 kW
Charging Rate (DC)—400 kW
V2L—3.3 kW
Drivetrain
TransmissionConventional AutomaticSingle Ratio Automatic
Transmission Name8-speed Steptronic—
Gears8—
Transmission ManufacturerZF—
DrivelineAll Wheel DriveRear Wheel Drive
Performance & Efficiency
0-100 km/h8.5 seconds6.5 seconds✓
Top Speed215 km/h✓200 km/h
Dimensions
Length4,755 mm4,705 mm
Width1,920 mm1,920 mm
Height1,660 mm1,705 mm
Wheelbase2,865 mm2,900 mm
Weight—2,260 kg
Doors55
Seats55
Boot Space570 litres630 litres✓
Front Tyre245/50R19255/45R20
Rear Tyre245/50R19255/45R20
Spare TyreN/A, Tyre Repair Kit—
Factory TyresContinental EcoContact 6 QContinental EcoContact 7
Wiper Blade (Driver)24 inch24 inch
Wiper Blade (Passenger)19 inch20 inch
Chassis
AssemblyMalaysia (CKD)China (CBU)
Front SuspensionMacPherson StrutDouble Wishbones
Rear SuspensionMulti-linkMulti-link
Front Wheels19" Y-spoke M Alloys20" Alloys
Rear Wheels19" Y-spoke M Alloys20" Alloys
SteeringRack & Pinion (Electric Power Steering)Rack and Pinion (Electric Power Steering)
Safety
Airbags6 (Driver and Front Passenger, Front Side, Curtain Airbags)6 (Driver & Front Passenger, Side Airbags, Curtain Airbags)
ABS/EBD✓✓
Stability Control✓✓
Alarm✓✓
Immobilizer✓✓
Airbag Disable Function✓✓
Child Safety LockManual for Rear DoorsElectronic for Rear Doors
Seat Belts5 Three-point5 Three-point
Blind Spot Info System✓✓
ISOFIXAvailable for 2 Outer Rear SeatsAvailable On Front Passenger Seat, Rear Outer Seats
Autonomous Braking SystemYesYes, Front and Rear
Lane-keeping AssistSteering CorrectionSteering Correction
Collision Warning✓✓
Seatbelt ReminderAll SeatsAll Seats
Lighting
HeadlampsLED ProjectorLED Projectors with Auto High Beam & Auto Levelling
TaillampsFull LEDFull LED
LED Daytime Running Lights✓✓
Rear Foglamps✓✓
Wing Mirror Turn Indicators✓✓
Cabin
Front SeatsPowered Front SeatsDriver and Passenger Powered Seats
Rear Seats40:20:40 Split-folding60:40 Split-fold with Sliding Adjustment
Front Air-conDual-zone Automatic Climate ControlDual-zone Automatic Climate Control
Rear Air-conSingle-zone Automatic Climate ControlRear AC Vents
Sunroof—Panoramic Glass Roof
Power Sockets1 Front, 1 Wireless Charger, 2 USB-C Front, 2 USB-C Rear1 Front, 2 Wireless Chargers, 2 USB-C Front, 2 USB-C Rear
Interior LightingMap Lights & Ambient LightingMap Lights & Ambient Lighting
Cup Holders2 Front, 2 Rear2 Front, 2 Rear
Sun Shade—Powered Sunroof Shade
Audio14.9" BMW Curved Display Live Cockpit Professional, 6 Speaker13" Twin AMOLED Touchscreens with Wireless Apple CarPlay & Android Auto, 20-speaker Sennheiser Sound System
Convenience
Power WindowsFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti-pinchFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti Pinch
Engine StartKeyless Push ButtonKeyless (Depress Brake Pedal)
LocksKeyless OperationKeyless Operation
Auto Start/Stop✓—
Auto Headlamps✓✓
Auto Wipers✓✓
Cruise ControlAdaptive Cruise ControlAdaptive Cruise Control with Highway & Traffic Jam Assist
Paddle Shift✓—
Steering Audio Control✓✓
Steering Tilt✓✓
Steering Telescopic✓✓
Boot OperationPowered Boot with Contactless OpeningYes, Powered with Kick Sensor
Parking Sensor Front6 Sensors6 Sensors
Parking Sensor Rear6 Sensors6 Sensors
Reverse CameraYes, 360-degree View MonitorYes, With 360-degree Camera
Auto ParkingYesYes
Folding Wing Mirrors✓✓
Bluetooth✓✓
Navigation✓✓
Head-up Display✓✓
Hill Start Assist✓✓
Instrument ClusterFull LCD MonitorFull LCD Monitor
Parking BrakeElectronicElectronic
Warranty
Warranty Mileage ManufacturerUnlimitedUnlimited
Warranty Mileage ExtendedUnlimited—
Warranty Manufacturer2 years4 years✓
Warranty Extended3 years—
Warranty Notes—8-year/200,000 km Battery Warranty & 8-year/150000 High Voltage Components Warranty

Specs shown for the selected variant of each car. ✓ marks the better figure where lower/higher is objectively better. Road tax: West Malaysia, private registration. Running-cost estimates assume 20,000 km/year. Fuel at RM1.99/litre (RON95, subsidised). Electricity at RM0.44/kWh (TNB domestic, home charging); public DC charging costs around RM1.30/kWh. Charging times estimated from battery capacity and peak charging rates. Insurance: comprehensive motor tariff, no NCD. Instalment: 10% down, 2.5% flat rate, 9 years. Prices checked November 2026.

Our reviews & guides

X3 vs #5 FAQ

Is the BMW X3 or smart #5 better?

The smart #5 is the stronger choice on price, performance, range, charging and boot space. Choose the BMW X3 specifically for all-wheel drive, Malaysian CKD assembly and its 215 km/h top speed.

What is the price difference?

The BMW X3 costs RM325,800 and the smart #5 costs RM209,800, so the BMW is RM116,000 more expensive.

Which one is faster and easier to charge?

The smart #5 is faster, reaching 100 km/h in 6.5 seconds versus 8.5 seconds for the X3. It also supports 22 kW AC and 400 kW DC charging; the petrol X3 does not require EV charging.

How long does charging take?

The #5's 100.0 kWh battery takes about 4.5 hours for a full AC charge, and an estimated 20 minutes from 10% to 80% on a DC fast charger at its 400 kW peak.

Which has the better warranty?

The #5 carries a 4-year manufacturer warranty against 2 years for the X3. #5: 8-year/200,000 km Battery Warranty & 8-year/150000 High Voltage Components Warranty.

More comparisons

Buying one of these? Sell your old car, get paid in 24 hours