Protectionism without competition is a liability, foreign investors welcomed to support local industry – MITI

Protectionism without competition is a liability, foreign investors welcomed to support local industry – MITI

Speaking at the launch of the MCE Auto Hub in Serendah today, minister of investment, trade and industry Datuk Seri Johari Abdul Ghani said that locally assembled (CKD) vehicles’ local content must include value creation, and that the rise of CBU (fully imported) vehicles puts the supplier ecosystem in Malaysia at risk.

Story continues after ad

While the aforementioned safeguarding measures are crucial, the minister also said that the protection of the Malaysian automotive industry without permitting competition will become a liability.

“We are cognisant that that protection without competitiveness will inevitably become a liability. Industries insulated from competition rarely become global leaders, as success must come from continuous innovation,” the MITI minister said.

Protectionism without competition is a liability, foreign investors welcomed to support local industry – MITI

“This is precisely why our approach to foreign investment remains transparent. We welcome foreign automotive players to establish and expand their presence in Malaysia, to coexist and complement our domestic ecosystem,” he continued.

Whenever he is approached by an investor asking for approvals, Johari says he tells them that Malaysia is “not a place only to sell cars. We want you to come and bring all the technologies, all the components, so that you can use Malaysia as a hub,” he said.

Story continues after ad

“I can understand that no investment can give you 100% localisation on day one, but at least, after some time being here in Malaysia, we want a substantial component of car manufacturing to involve real and effective localisation,” he added.

Protectionism without competition is a liability, foreign investors welcomed to support local industry – MITI

The ministry of investment, trade and industry was accused of protectionism through its new policy for fully imported EVs that it confirmed in May. This stipulated that any EV being imported must have a minimum declared cost, insurance and freight (CIF) value of RM200,000, and a minimum power output of 180 kW (which is equivalent to 245 PS or 241 hp).

In March this year, MITI issued a statement following a news report indicating that the ministry imposed terms on BYD for its CKD local assembly plans, which the Chinese conglomerate could not agree to.

In the initial report cited, Johari stated the need to protect the local auto industry. “You must also remember that both Proton and Perodua have 50% local content in their cars, and Proton sells about 150,000 cars a year [while] Perodua sells about 350,000, which is a lot, and these two companies built much of the existing ecosystem for the auto industry in Malaysia. So, we have to protect them.”

In its response statement, MITI stated: “Together, Proton and Perodua have channelled billions into the Malaysian vendor ecosystem, supporting thousands of SMEs, skilled employees, and communities across the country. This is the industrial standard we are working to replicate.”

Looking to sell your car? Sell it with Carro for the best price.

Filed under:
Local News
Sell your car, get paid in 24 hours
Comments

  1. comment avatar Najib
    Nak tongkat cakap je la
    Thumb up 41 Thumb down 1 Reply
    • comment avatar Sohai
      Sohai punya MITI, u ask foreign investor come to invest multimillion but in reality their investment will
      Lost because EV car product CANNOT SELL well in market because EV CAR PRICE still very much EXPENSIVE than PETROL CAR. By right EV CAR simply & lower parts should be cheaper. MITI should immediate restructure EV CAR TAX compare to PETROL CAR TAX.
      Thumb up 6 Thumb down 0 Reply
    • comment avatar FrankC
      kenapa kita tak boleh export kereta ke negara lain ?
      kerana tariff dan sekatan yg membuatkan exoport ke negara tersebut tidak menguntungkan. semua negara ada polisi yg memberi perlindungan kepada sektor automotif masing masing. kita punya protectionism bukan sesuatu yg baru di dunia automlotif
      Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0 Reply
  2. comment avatar ultra
    Sembang BN. Padahal nak protect crony.
    Thumb up 35 Thumb down 0 Reply
  3. comment avatar Wonderwhy
    This is definately what chinese say "USE LUNG TO TALK"
    Thumb up 16 Thumb down 0 Reply
  4. comment avatar apa lagi mau
    thank you johari for protek proton and perodua
    Thumb up 3 Thumb down 37 Reply
  5. comment avatar BCG
    How come Tesla has special treatment? Bottom line is your are protecting your cronies and you are giving all your stupid terms and condition to BYD
    Thumb up 62 Thumb down 18 Reply
    • comment avatar Sabri
      please attack the right people. cronies and AP KINGS not tesla. bodoh ke.
      Thumb up 1 Thumb down 1 Reply
  6. comment avatar Boy Racer
    Since day 1, it's all about protecting a few deep pockets.

    Every other day release another rubbish statement. Why Johari? Your cronies pressuring you is it, or you want to reassure them?

    It reminds me of a quote. “Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools, because they have to say something.”
    Thumb up 29 Thumb down 0 Reply
    • comment avatar yes
      like how bung used to say "pak you"
      Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0 Reply
  7. comment avatar Syd
    No conditions for proton and perodua to export. Not even to fellow asean countries as they tried and failed.
    Thumb up 16 Thumb down 0 Reply
    • comment avatar Bung Corn Holio
      p1 and p2 will NEVER be able to export anything. TO be honest, government should seriously consider letting them survive on their own without tongkat. If they fail, so be it. Malaysian consumers are so tired of them.
      Thumb up 20 Thumb down 0 Reply
  8. comment avatar Sabri
    Support your crony kan
    Thumb up 23 Thumb down 1 Reply
  9. comment avatar Johnny
    BS lah, just say you want to keep protecting P1 and P2. Low volume sales for foreign brands will not attract them to invest here. No investment, no new jobs.
    Thumb up 9 Thumb down 0 Reply
  10. comment avatar ThePolygon
    Tesla apa macam? *Special*
    Thumb up 44 Thumb down 39 Reply
    • comment avatar Sabri
      ur bmw got build petrol station?
      Thumb up 2 Thumb down 2 Reply
      • comment avatar dodo brisab
        if it were as simple as building chargers, BYD could easily build a network of them in malaysia.
        Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0 Reply
  11. comment avatar ThePolygon
    I am sure BYD would gladly install their chargers to get the *special* treatment like Tesla. Or that deal is only for Tesla?
    Thumb up 51 Thumb down 36 Reply
  12. comment avatar FireAce
    "Foreign Investors Welcomed" with below terms and conditions

    1. You can only sell 2 out of 10 cars you assemble here. The rest must be exported.
    2. The 2 cars you sell here must be of higher price range model that do not compete with Proton & Perodua.
    3. There are also unspoken unofficial rules that you must hire certain people, use certain vendors. We will casually "recommend" the details/names during one of the entertainment session later.
    4. We reserved the right to change the terms and conditions (including the 3 above) anytime and anyway we want. Even if we already signed agreement and your factory half way build.
    5. If you decide to abandon the project for any reasons, we will enforce the "exit clause" and seek compensation based on agreement signed.
    Thumb up 15 Thumb down 0 Reply
  13. comment avatar kk
    really.... this dude knows what the sxxt he is talking about?
    Thumb up 6 Thumb down 0 Reply
  14. comment avatar Sohai
    Sohai punya MITI. EV car should have new different tax structure where it should tax much lower than petrol car. Then it will auto-switch consumer buying cheap cheap EV and auto-saving petrol subsidy. When targeted >80% drive EV then your petrol subsidy also drop 80% too.
    Thumb up 5 Thumb down 0 Reply
  15. comment avatar Ben Yap
    nevermind, still got PHEV and ICE cars to buy... no need EV.
    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 1 Reply
  16. comment avatar Kea Was
    Problem here is which cronies to support and which one to benefit at the expense of everyone else example of our national company giving us low quality products for decades.
    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0 Reply
Featured Stories