Paul Tan's Automotive Industry News

Mercedes Benz may pull out of Formula 1?

Advertisement

The latest addition to the hot rumor pot is the possibility of Stuttgart-based auto maker Mercedes Benz pulling out of Formula 1 as the recent “lie-gate” scandal involving the McLaren Formula 1 team intensifies. Apparently, Daimler AG’s CEO, Dieter Zetsche has revealed to a German-based publication that, “If circumstances should change, perhaps because of an unreasonable punishment by the FIA, it is possible that we could consider our engagement,”.

In a couple of days, the World Motor Sport Council will meet and a decision will be issued out regarding the scandal that involves the McLaren outfit not being truthful regarding the yellow flag incident at the 2009 season opener in Melbourne, Australia.

The Woking-based outfit is expected to face severe penalties, and it does make sense for Mercedes to think about pulling out if it feels that the FIA’s decision is unreasonable. The premium brand is not only supplying its V8 powerplants to McLaren, but to two other teams as well, including the slower Force India and Brawn GP.

38 Comments »

  1. AlfaRomeo=Ferrari’sCousin said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 12:45 pm

    Wise move . . .

  2. MSC said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 12:55 pm

    might be huge to Brawn GP

  3. bmpower said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 1:19 pm

    FIA biased ferrari.
    always hate mclaren.
    gth fia!

  4. gangully said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 1:29 pm

    yeah! they are so biased towards ferrari that they deemed the 2 step diffuser used by Brawn GP, Toyota and Williams legal!

    so bl00dy biased!

  5. bolo said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 1:55 pm

    This is Daimler AG’s way telling FIA not to push them around too much…Many years ago it was Ferrari who felt aggrieved by FIA’s engine regulation. So Enzo Ferrari threatened to quit F1 join Indy cars (CART) instead. The old man even went so far as to build a complete CART spec race car and unveiled to the public to blackmail FIA. http://forix.autosport.com/8w/march90ca-ferrari.html

    On the diffuser issue, it was classic F1 way of reading the rules. Colin Chapman once said “rules is for the obedience of fools and interpretation of wise men”, it was that attitude that gave the world ground effect and dual chassis F1 cars.

  6. leonardo said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 2:37 pm

    It will be sad if Mclaren pulls out from F1, but then it is their own doing. They lied and thought they could get away with it.

    Ferarri is till struggling with just 3 points after 3 races because they thought that they were still the same powerful team that won the constructors award last year. Unfortunately the new rule changes have wiped the slate clean and everyone starts from zero, and Ferrari were caught unprepared. I believe they will catch up with the rest in the middle of the season.

  7. Dyky said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 2:52 pm

    McLaren deserves no glory in the filed of Formula 1!

  8. layman said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 3:00 pm

    McLaren Mercedes tak laku lagi, sekarang kita ada BrawnGP Mercedes yang lagi hebat.

  9. theanswer said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 3:10 pm

    [quote comment="234215"]yeah! they are so biased towards ferrari that they deemed the 2 step diffuser used by Brawn GP, Toyota and Williams legal!

    so bl00dy biased![/quote]

    for the last 2-3 seasons of f1, most new rules intro by FIA are to reduced ferrari(or to be exact schumi) domination in F1..so do u really think that FIA is biased towards ferrari? think abt that.

  10. gangully said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 3:40 pm

    theanswer, if you can’t sense the sarcasm i intended in my message in response to bmpower’s comment… then i am now telling you…

    THAT WAS SARCASM IN RESPONSE TO BMPOWER’S COMMENT!

  11. gangully said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 3:43 pm

    theanswer, if you did not sense my sarcasm in my response to bmpower’s comments… then i am telling you that

    “my comment was sarcasm to bmpower’s comment that “fia biased ferrari”"

    geddit?

  12. Sean said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 3:58 pm

    The fact that this is Mercedes pulling out…..Mclaren is a different name all together…yes Mclaren recently made a lot of errors and its their fault but the fault cannot be shared with Mercedes since they did not do anything wrong from the beginning so with Mercedes pulling out….F1 will never be the same and its not worth watching F1 anymore…imagine having a name like Ferrari pulling out from the race. What’s left to watch?

  13. wrongturn said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 4:23 pm

    Why should Mercedes pulling out of F1 when Brawn doing pretty well? It is the McLaren shall be the one feeling the pinch…
    Mercedes pulling out from McLaren….aaa dats something else!

  14. Najib said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 4:51 pm

    F1 without direct involvement of Big Name car makers is still F1. and i emphasize here DIRECT. i mean F1 used to be a sport in which independent teams utilizing car makers engines with little or no direct involvement with the major car makers and we still watch it :) ….well i’ve been following F1 ever since I can remember (i think since the late 80’s or early 90’s. i still remember how great the Williams team used to be, or how Steward Ford and Jordan Grand Prix won races without direct involvement of car makers

  15. azrai said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 5:00 pm

    FIA seem to be quite biased to Ferrari. Do we ever wonder why.

  16. KeithDuckworth said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 5:25 pm

    Mercedes owns a share in McLaren so I think chances of them pulling out from McLaren and then support Brawn is very unlikely. If Mercedes decides to drop F1, chances are that Brawn will also have to find another engine supplier. True ?

  17. osh_kosh said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 5:27 pm

    FIA will always biased toward Ferrari in the eyes of McLaren fanboys…. pathetic… during ‘Spy-gate’ drama, why on earth Alonso & Hammy being allowed to still go racing? didn’t it mean that they’re racing with ‘drugged’ horses? they could still win Driver Championship, remember? i didn’t heard anyone saying FIA biased to McLaren!

    anyway, in recent case, McLaren & Hammy only got themself to blame! What it got to do with Ferrari? stupid… some ppl would love to point finger to others… if McLaren being ban for the rest of this year races, I still think Ferrari can’t win Constructor Championship, unless they got some bloody amasing updates coming in Barcelona.. but so do other teams & that mean it will not be easy for Ferrari… so Ferrari basicly gain nothing! i don’t see how can they gain in long-term either (if McLaren-Merc pull out of F1)! FIA should just punish MCLaren & LW pretty hard coz they’ve been given a few chances to correct themself but choosed not to! I don’t have any respect to a liar! Liar! Liar! Pans on Fire!

  18. bmpower said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 7:07 pm

    giving ferrari 800million more winning money is not a biased?
    wth on earth was that?

    This year, it’s out of what FIA draft script .
    they just didn’t expect that the Brawn team was hell great!.
    no one expect that too.

    So it’s not about not helping ferrari. but it’s just about merz doing other trick to prove their engine are better than ferrari.

    Before this, what mclaren merz had is a very good aerodynamic car over than ferrari. That’s why so many thing applied as a ‘new rule’.

    Sadly.. all FIA (and ferrari) was out of their plan .
    Brawn mercedes just fail all of their plan. (and they keep giving out their angry to Mclaren this and that )

    If you can see that, and still saying that Mclaren is ‘lied’. so then.. I knew… You’re just a pure Ferarri Blind Fan.

    and if.. brawn will conquer this upcoming 3 year of champion.. then so called ferrari fan just be ‘a Brawn team supporter instead’. They are just a person those ’support those win’.

  19. bmpower said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 7:10 pm

    oh btw.. im not mclaren blind fan.
    nor brawn supporter to death.

    i am kubica fan . and BMW Sauber supporter.
    even thought they are not winner.. but surely someday they will..

  20. kent w said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 7:22 pm

    I hate Merc the most…. Involved in so many F1 scandal. Never heard any others team having this problem also…

  21. osh_kosh said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 8:27 pm

    yeah right… all i heard every now & then r that Ferrari received this money that money, as if that all those Money r fabricated to ‘flow’ into their arm… if it isn’t fair i wonder why McLaren-Merc (or any other teams) still here all this time, & not making a big fuss about it (only their fans r)…. F1 is not “village” football, it’s a multi-millions sports/business, if u can’t benefit by entering it then why bother? if it’s being ‘manipulate’ by a few ppl to suite their favourite team, why bother? think about it… all i heard was rumours with no basis, give me solid facts (such as Hammy radio transmission etc.) then i will believe… the team (plus LH) admitted (at last) that it was their mistake & didn’t even mentioned that the penalty given to them (to date) r not fair! all i heard r their fans whining like it was all FIA/Stewards/Ferrari(or even Toyota) guys just want to kick them down.. gosh…

    btw, i’m no Ferrari fan.. i’m more interested in drivers rather than teams.. my fav. still Kimi, Vettel & Nico.. used to like Hammy before the Alonso-LH-McLaren hanky-panky.. but I never like Alonso… superb driver but IMO he’s a cry-baby..

  22. mystvearn said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 9:03 pm

    FIA will not suspend Mclaren, will never happen. Want less cars on the grid? Don’t think so. They will give out a fine only. No point deduction as Mclaren are nowhere now.

  23. Khim Foh said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 9:31 pm

    Daimler AG’s CEO, Dieter Zetsche is using this so called ‘lie-gate’ as a excuse to pull out of Formula one because like most car manufacturers, they are feeling the heat of diminishing demand of cars due to the global economic crisis which is hitting the car manufacturers where it hurts.

    Honda has pulled out and Toyota will pull out if the F1 team does not make successful inroads into F1; i.e must win the championship in order to justify its substantial investment cost. Renault will be on shaky ground next season because it’s main sponsor ING will pull of out F1.

    Also I don’t why Daimler AG is so concerned about the lie-gate as they should be thrilled to bits that BrawnGP which by the way is powered by a Mercedes F1 engine (which by the way is designed and build entirely by it’s British based subsidiary Ilmor Engineering) is winning races.

    I personally doubt Daimler AG is concerned about the lying fiasco because heck everybody lies one point or another. Being a hypocrite is what Daimler AG is only good at at the current moment.

  24. f1 said,

    April 27, 2009 @ 11:30 pm

    SSo naive that some of u think other teams dont lie just that they didnt get
    caught/sabo by d FIA stewards like mclaren. D FIA nowadays cannot b reliable
    coz they r really flip flops & decisions can change anytime after d race.

    Even Bernie is worried that merc pulling out which would mean less commercial money & hinted there b a FAIR punishment for mclaren.

    Hope all this liegate is finish & finalised by wednesday no more flip flops.

  25. scanzew said,

    April 28, 2009 @ 12:44 am

    yeah….FIArarri..

  26. scanzew said,

    April 28, 2009 @ 12:50 am

    [quote comment="234239"]McLaren Mercedes tak laku lagi, sekarang kita ada BrawnGP Mercedes yang lagi hebat.[/quote]

    BrawnGP very laju because it’s diffusser..after bahrain GP..ferrari and mclaren start to dominance again..it’s aerodinamic..and the end of diffuser row team..

    farewell for BrawnGP, Williams & Toyota………

  27. MrAmoi said,

    April 28, 2009 @ 9:59 am

    -Bmpower
    So we are bothers huh? I am also one of the BMW supporters. It is sad that nick and kubica raced poorly in the last two races. Hope they’ll pick up soon.

    If Mercedes really pull out from F1, who is going to supply the power plants to Brawn GP and meclaren? Will mclaren go back to its old day’s Mclaren Honda? Hmmm……

  28. JULIAN_LEE said,

    April 28, 2009 @ 10:27 am

    Merc can blah… BMW better…

  29. MrAmoi said,

    April 28, 2009 @ 12:40 pm

    Bmpower-
    Looks like we’re bothers huh? I am also one of the bmw supporters! nick and kubica are not doing very well for the last few races…hope they’ll pick up soon.

    If mercedes really quit f1, what is going to happend to mclaren and brawn? Will merc go back to the old Mclaren honda and then hires arton senna’s nephew to be the driver? hm….

  30. stroller said,

    April 29, 2009 @ 9:46 am

    too many politics in f1 nowaday.. biased to popular team especially the scarlet red…

  31. NutzeyWagen said,

    April 29, 2009 @ 1:23 pm

    It’ll be a crying shame if Mercedes go ahead with their threat to pull out from F1. Mercedes in F1 is not just about McLaren, there’s also Force India and the Championship leading Brawn GP. True F1 fans would definitely want them to remain, but if Mercedes does pull out, the biggest losers would be the Brawn GP team. Why punish all for the mistake of one? Fans would be hoping that cooler heads will prevail, and the threat remains just a threat. CHIAO!

  32. MyBoy said,

    April 29, 2009 @ 2:48 pm

    [quote comment="234248"]theanswer, if you did not sense my sarcasm in my response to bmpower’s comments… then i am telling you that

    “my comment was sarcasm to bmpower’s comment that “fia biased ferrari”"

    geddit?[/quote]
    You know what bro. Some guy need to learn english. :D

  33. MyBoy said,

    April 29, 2009 @ 3:29 pm

    [quote comment="234241"][quote comment="234215"]yeah! they are so biased towards ferrari that they deemed the 2 step diffuser used by Brawn GP, Toyota and Williams legal!

    so bl00dy biased![/quote]

    for the last 2-3 seasons of f1, most new rules intro by FIA are to reduced ferrari(or to be exact schumi) domination in F1..so do u really think that FIA is biased towards ferrari? think abt that.[/quote]
    He just being sarcastic lah bro.

  34. MyBoy said,

    April 29, 2009 @ 3:38 pm

    [quote comment="234392"][quote comment="234239"]McLaren Mercedes tak laku lagi, sekarang kita ada BrawnGP Mercedes yang lagi hebat.[/quote]

    BrawnGP very laju because it’s diffusser..after bahrain GP..ferrari and mclaren start to dominance again..it’s aerodinamic..and the end of diffuser row team..

    farewell for BrawnGP, Williams & Toyota………[/quote]
    Redbull using standard diffuser all along and still extremely competitive. How do you explain that?

  35. JJose Carlos said,

    April 29, 2009 @ 9:27 pm

    I thnk FIA has made huge changes to chalenge Schumi, so, I don’t believe they love Ferrari that much. But I think they have something with McLaren, and what Daimler boss did was a threat to show these guys that F1 can’t afford to lose such a powerhouse like Mercedes-Benz.

  36. scanzew said,

    April 30, 2009 @ 11:18 pm

    [quote comment="234802"][quote comment="234392"][quote comment="234239"]McLaren Mercedes tak laku lagi, sekarang kita ada BrawnGP Mercedes yang lagi hebat.[/quote]

    BrawnGP very laju because it’s diffusser..after bahrain GP..ferrari and mclaren start to dominance again..it’s aerodinamic..and the end of diffuser row team..

    farewell for BrawnGP, Williams & Toyota………[/quote]
    Redbull using standard diffuser all along and still extremely competitive. How do you explain that?[/quote]

    Redbull don’t hav KERS and make it’s their car more light than other car..furthermore a skill driver like vettel

  37. osh_kosh said,

    May 1, 2009 @ 5:02 pm

    look like the ‘threat’ work just fine… LOL… so much for FIArari, biased or whatever…

  38. dr_farnz said,

    May 3, 2009 @ 12:41 pm

    Michael Schumacher + Ferrari + Ross Brawn =F1 all time champ and legend…

Leave a Comment

Log in

Please do not submit your comment twice, the system has accepted your comment, it just needs to be moderated first. Once your first comment is approved, all subsequent comments will show automatically.

previous post: MITI to rethink Approved Permit system
next post: U.S pricing for BMW X5 M and BMW X6 M leaks out